Your email address is safe with us. View our Privacy policy.
Author Bio:
Richard Cohen's columns have appeared on the op-ed page of The Washington Post since 1984. He joined The Post in 1968 after attending the Columbia ...
Read more about Richard Cohen.
Richard Cohen's columns have appeared on the op-ed page of The Washington Post since 1984. He joined The Post in 1968 after attending the Columbia ...
Read more about Richard Cohen.
Obama's a Prettily Wrapped Package, But Who Knows What's Inside?
Richard Cohen
"Just tell me one thing Barack Obama has done that you admire," I
asked a prominent Democrat. He paused and then said that he admired
Obama's speech to the Democratic convention in 2004. I agreed. It was
a hell of a speech, but it was just a speech.
On the other hand, I continued, I could cite four or five actions -- not speeches -- that John McCain has taken that elicit my admiration, even my awe. First, of course, is his decision as a Vietnam War POW to refuse freedom out of concern that he would be exploited for propaganda purposes. To paraphrase what Kipling said about Gunga Din, John McCain is a better man than most.
But I would not stop there. I would include campaign finance reform, which infuriated so many in his own party; opposition to earmarks, which won him no friends; his politically imprudent opposition to the Medicare prescription drug bill (Medicare has about $35 trillion in unfunded obligations); and, last but not least, his very early call for additional troops in Iraq. His was a lonely position, virtually suicidal for an all-but-certain presidential candidate, and no help when his campaign nearly expired last summer. In all these cases, McCain stuck to his guns.
Obama argues that he himself stuck to the biggest gun of all: opposition to the war. He took that position back when the war was enormously popular, the president who initiated it was even more popular, and critics of both were slandered as unpatriotic. But at the time, Obama was a mere Illinois state senator, representing the (very) liberal Hyde Park area of Chicago. He either voiced his conscience or his district's leanings or (lucky fella) both. We will never know.
And we will never know, either, how Obama might have conducted himself had he served in Congress as long as McCain has. Possibly he would have earned a reputation for furious, maybe even sanctimonious, integrity of the sort that often drove McCain's colleagues to dark thoughts of senatorcide, but the record -- scant as it is -- suggests otherwise. Obama is not noted for sticking to a position or a person once it (or he) becomes a political liability. (Names available upon request.)
All politicians change their positions, sometimes even because they have changed their mind. McCain must have suffered excruciating whiplash from totally reversing himself on George Bush's tax cuts. He has denounced preachers he later embraced and then, to his chagrin, has had to denounce them all over again. This plasticity has a label: Pandering. McCain knows how it's done.
But Obama has shown that in this area, youth is no handicap. He has been for and against gun control, against and for the recent domestic surveillance legislation and, in almost a single day, for a united Jerusalem under Israeli control and then, when apprised of U.S. policy and Palestinian chagrin, against it. He is an accomplished pol -- a statement of both admiration and a bit of regret.
Obama is often likened to John F. Kennedy. It makes sense. He has the requisite physical qualities -- handsome, lean, etc. -- plus wit, intelligence, awesome speaking abilities and a literary bent. He also might be compared to Franklin D. Roosevelt for many of those same qualities. Both FDR and JFK were disparaged early on by their contemporaries for, I think, doing the difficult and making it look easy. Eleanor Roosevelt, playing off the title of Kennedy's Pulitzer Prize-winning book, airily dismissed him as more profile than courage. Similarly, it was Walter Lippmann's enduring misfortune to size up FDR and belittle him: Roosevelt, he wrote, was "a pleasant man who, without any important qualifications for office, would very much like to be president." Lippmann later recognized that he had underestimated Roosevelt.
My guess is that Obama will make a fool of anyone who issues such a judgment about him. Still, the record now, while tissue thin, is troubling. The next president will have to be something of a political Superman, a man of steel who can tell the American people that they will have to pay more for less -- higher taxes, lower benefits of all kinds -- and deal in an ugly way when nuclear weapons seize the imagination of madmen.
The question I posed to that prominent Democrat was just my way of thinking out loud. I know that Barack Obama is a near-perfect political package. I'm still not sure, though, what's in it.
========
Richard Cohen's e-mail address is cohenr@washpost.com
(c) 2008, Washington Post Writers Group
This news arrived on: 07/29/2008
Printer Friendly Version | Send this page to a friend | Post Comment
Rate This Story:
Great - 5 - 4 - 3 - 2 - 1 - Bad
Posted Comments:
07-30-2008 14:07
Jim wrote:
What a bunch of crepe hangers have written in response to the news report, not to mention the writer!!!
What has missing for a while has been someone who can raise consciousness, bring people to the ramparts and the red glare, and start punching.
Americans are like wilted lettuce and cabbage leaves right now. Here at last, his someone who is raising sights, lifting spirits, telling us we can do it.
Not sit there and criticize others on whom we have no evidence. Perhaps four years of someone who exicites us about our country and what we can do is what we need, NOT someone who is going to do it. American hasn't had a really good coach.
Look what happens to a losing football team, when a new coach comes in a lights a fire under them.
The players do it. Not the coach. He provides the stimulus. Obama is showing he can be a stimulus. But we Americans need to do it.
I hear and read a lot of complaining about the man they know so little about. Why don't you read two of his books and learn a little. Of course, you'd have to work at that, just as we need to do to get this country great.
What has missing for a while has been someone who can raise consciousness, bring people to the ramparts and the red glare, and start punching.
Americans are like wilted lettuce and cabbage leaves right now. Here at last, his someone who is raising sights, lifting spirits, telling us we can do it.
Not sit there and criticize others on whom we have no evidence. Perhaps four years of someone who exicites us about our country and what we can do is what we need, NOT someone who is going to do it. American hasn't had a really good coach.
Look what happens to a losing football team, when a new coach comes in a lights a fire under them.
The players do it. Not the coach. He provides the stimulus. Obama is showing he can be a stimulus. But we Americans need to do it.
I hear and read a lot of complaining about the man they know so little about. Why don't you read two of his books and learn a little. Of course, you'd have to work at that, just as we need to do to get this country great.
07-30-2008 10:52
Linda wrote:
Cohen on Obama
I am as far right as you can get without turning radical...I hope there are more Cohen-thinking Democrats out there than it appears. The media has already crowned Obama King. Most Americans are too busy to really pay attention to politics and go by what they see and hear on the main stream media....if this stays true I am afraid we are in trouble come November!
07-30-2008 10:32
AnneB-IL wrote:
I hope these articles questioning Obama's qualification aren't too little, too late. We in Illinois know that he has been too busy running for the next highest office to represent us! And with no qualifications except he can give a good speech - just the kind of president we need in these times! We need to wake up before November or we will be in worse trouble than we are now!
07-30-2008 09:20
Justice wrote:
obama
JFK one of our greatest??? Are you kidding me. He was in office for 2 1/2 years and caused the bay of pigs. What great thing did he do? Just because he was assasinated is why everyone says he was great. Not on deeds.
07-30-2008 08:34
Abbe wrote:
Obama
Near perfect? And the guys you mentioned that you think he's like? What happened to them?
I don't believe Obama measures up to anything. Speeches are nothing but words. After he got elected senator what did he do? He jumped up and started running for President, that is what. Some accomplishment. Sounds like an ego trip to me.
I don't believe Obama measures up to anything. Speeches are nothing but words. After he got elected senator what did he do? He jumped up and started running for President, that is what. Some accomplishment. Sounds like an ego trip to me.
Comment archive | Comment FAQ's
 |
 |
|
View Richard Cohen ezine stories by date or visit the complete archive |
The ArcaMax Politics channel is one of 70 content categories offered by ArcaMax Publishing on this ... |
Body Mass
